Fill It Up Friday- Let's Go There, the ADHD debate

-

Fill it up Friday
Each Friday we will look at an article to fill up on the whys of teaching.
 
I wanted to share this article since I had seen it floating around on social media.  I'll give you a minute to read it.  Seriously, you go read it and I'll wait right here.

Ok good now that you've read it I want to know what you think.  ADHD can be a controversial topic in general, but the assertion that there is a subset of preschoolers (or in this case 2 and 3 year olds) that not only have ADHD but are suffering enough to need medication is alarming. I'm going to start off by saying that this article does not give all the facts.  It does not give exact figures and is estimating the rate of medicating children in other areas based on one state.  Without having hard and fast numbers it is hard to know how accurate the reporting is. 

It is also difficult to determine from the article why these children were prescribed the medication.  They could be using the medication for an off-label use.  Off-label usage often has advantages in cases where traditional treatments are not working.  There could be instances within the reported numbers where the treatment is not for ADHD but some other condition where all other treatments have failed.
The concern for me arises if (and this is the danger in reading non-specific reporting) and only if young children are being diagnosed with ADHD.  By their inherent nature young children are impulsive and active.  If as a society we look at this and think that it is something to "fix" then we as a society are the ones that truly need the fixing.  If we as educators are not providing developmentally appropriate learning environments for our children then we need to adjust our pedagogy.  If we as advocates for our young ones cannot provide support for parents to understand what to expect from their children and how to support them then we need to search for the words.

We work so hard in this country to allow all persons to be themselves.  We fight for equality and freedom of expression for all.  We believe that everyone has the right to be themselves in whichever fashion suits them best and yet we force unrealistic expectations on children at all levels and expect them to just bend to our wills. 

"Be the change you wish to see in the world." Stand up for our children in every arena you can.  This sometimes means questioning your pediatrician.  This means partnering with parents to find workable solutions.  This means assisting coworkers in finding new solutions for "difficult children."

With all of that said I do believe there are some humans (whether they are children or adults) who can benefit from medical intervention based on the variations of chemicals in their bodies.  This is not for everyone and should be done with extreme caution in children who are still growing at astronomical rates.
 

What do you think?  Have you faced issues like this with your own kids?  Your students?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Time-Out Tuesdays- Gardening

-
Image
Time-Out Tuesdays Each Tuesday we will take time out of the classroom to learn about each other. I love to (attempt to) grow my own veggies in the warm months.   I look forward to it each year.   This year was no different.   It was a rough winter in more than one way and I was so happy to have the warmth finally return. Last year I housed my container garden on my Grammy's porch.   She passed away this past November and the garden has come to be yet another reminder of her.   I'd like to think that it is doing so well this year because she has been watching over it from afar. We planted two types of tomatoes, green peppers, banana peppers, yellow squash, cucumber, spinach, and lettuce.   They are all doing so well this year!   Last year we had a rotten start and didn't near harvest until mid-June.   I think the lettuce and spinach will be good to go soon!   Banana Pepper Lettuce Tomato Bell Pepper Spinach ...
Read more

Fill It Up Friday- Screen Time

-
Image
Fill it up Friday Each Friday we will look at an article to fill up on the whys of teaching. Today we are going to look at an article that touches on a subject that impacts all of us- screen time.   I am shocked by the amount of time the average child in my school is sitting in front of a screen.   They not only watch television at home but now there are shows and games on phones, televisions mounted in the car, tablets, and computers that are accessible nearly 24/7. In the NAEYC publication, Beyond the Remote-Controlled Childhood , Dianne Levin addresses some topics that we encounter daily with our children.   One of my favorite terms that she puts forth is "age compression."    This is a term that labels something that many of us have been watching for years. Levin states, "age compression is a term used by media professionals and marketers to describe how children at ever-younger ages are doing what older children used to do (pg 33)."   WO...
Read more

Time-Out Tuesday- Whadda Work For?

-
Time-Out Tuesday Each Tuesday we will take time out of the classroom to learn about each other. Goals.... So nice to have. So hard to set sometimes. My problem is that I want to do EVERYTHING!  I'm not even sure what my next big goal should be.  Here are a few ideas I'm toying with: Another Master's- Maybe reading?  Doctorate- Early Childhood?  Ed Psych? Ed Instruction and Leadership? Pickup more TCC classes- Get online certified so I can teach online courses too (This one is in the works). Start doing trainings through my own rather than just through organizations? Get National Board Certified? Hmph.  So many ideas.  I must edit them down.  What are your goals? Where do you see yourself in the next 5 years?  If you know me in the real world, where do you see me in the next 5 years? 
Read more